Get 15% Off Your First Order →
Cart 0
Get 15% Off Your First Order →
Cart 0
Purple Pick Your Poison Babe Comfort Colors shirt featuring a Disney-inspired poison apple and potion bottles with stars and “I'm Poison Either Way” text, a Taylor Swift imgonnagetyouback mashup for Disney Halloween outfits.
Purple Pick Your Poison Babe Comfort Colors shirt featuring a Disney-inspired poison apple and potion bottles with stars and “I'm Poison Either Way” text, a Taylor Swift imgonnagetyouback mashup for Disney Halloween outfits.
Green Pick Your Poison Babe Comfort Colors shirt featuring a Disney-inspired poison apple and potion bottles with stars and “I'm Poison Either Way” text, a Taylor Swift imgonnagetyouback mashup for Disney Halloween outfits.
Beige Pick Your Poison Babe Comfort Colors shirt featuring a Disney-inspired poison apple and potion bottles with stars and “I'm Poison Either Way” text, a Taylor Swift imgonnagetyouback mashup for Disney Halloween outfits.
Black Pick Your Poison Babe Comfort Colors shirt featuring a Disney-inspired poison apple and potion bottles with stars and “I'm Poison Either Way” text, a Taylor Swift imgonnagetyouback mashup for Disney Halloween outfits.
A size chart graphic for the Comfort Colors shirt, showing a size table from S to 4XL with width, length, and sleeve center back measurements, alongside a gray short-sleeve T-shirt with arrows marking chest, length, and center back. Fit notes are listed below on a light beige background.

Pick Your Poison Babe Mashup Comfort Colors Shirt

$44.00 $0.00
Shipping calculated at checkout.

🍎 Pick Your Poison, Babe

I'm poison either way.

For the Disney Swiftie whose Halloween personality is equal parts pop lyrics, poisoned apples, suspicious potion bottles, and a little villain energy.

The Pick Your Poison Babe Mashup Shirt takes the lyric from imgonnagetyouback and drops it straight into a world of Disney-inspired poisons and potions—creating the kind of wildly specific fandom mashup that makes another fan stop you in the park and say, “WAIT. I love your shirt.”

With poison apple and potion-inspired artwork, this tee was practically made for Disney Halloween trips, Oogie Boogie Bash, Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party, Disneyland, Disney World, Halloween parties, and every Swiftie who likes her spooky season with a little attitude.

Printed on a premium Comfort Colors® garment-dyed tee, it has that soft, lived-in, vintage feel that's comfortable enough for a full park day.

Add biker shorts, jeans, sneakers, mouse ears, or your favorite villain-inspired accessories and consider your Halloween park outfit handled.

Pick your poison, babe. 🍎✨

✨ Shirt Details

  • Premium Comfort Colors® garment-dyed t-shirt

  • 100% ring-spun cotton

  • Soft, lived-in vintage feel

  • Heavyweight fabric

  • Relaxed unisex fit

  • Professionally printed

  • Made to order

📏 Fit Notes

This Comfort Colors® tee has a relaxed, structured unisex fit with that perfectly broken-in garment-dyed feel.

  • Order your usual size for the intended relaxed fit

  • Size down for a more fitted look

  • Size up 1–2 sizes for an oversized park-day fit

👉 See the size chart in the product photos for exact measurements.

🎃 Why You'll Love It

  • A clever imgonnagetyouback × Disney Halloween mashup

  • Poison apple and potion-inspired artwork made for spooky season

  • Perfect for Disney Swifties

  • An easy Halloween park outfit without wearing a costume

  • Premium Comfort Colors® garment-dyed cotton

  • Perfect for Oogie Boogie Bash and Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

  • Made for Disneyland, Disney World, Halloween parties, and fall park trips

  • The kind of niche fandom reference that gets compliments from people who get it

🎵 More Disney Swiftie + Halloween Mashups

When one fandom simply isn't enough.

👻 Haunted Mansion Holiday House — folklore meets the Haunted Mansion with a ghostly “I had a marvelous time ruining everything” twist.

🎠 Teacups Anti-Hero — Midnights meets the teacups ride for anyone willing to admit that yes, they're the problem spinning that thing.

🐈 Gorgeous Cats Halloween — Reputation meets ghost cats, pumpkins, bats, and the extremely relatable decision to stumble on home to your cats.

🧛 Style Vampire — That red lip classic thing that you like... except now it has fangs.

🏰 Karma x Mickey — Music meets Disney magic for the Swiftie whose karma always leads her right back to the parks.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

What inspired the Pick Your Poison Babe Shirt?

This design mashes up the “Pick your poison, babe, I'm poison either way” lyric from imgonnagetyouback with Disney-inspired poison apples and magical potion imagery for a spooky Disney Swiftie crossover.

Is this a good Disney Halloween shirt?

Absolutely! The poison and potion artwork gives it built-in Halloween energy while still being comfortable enough for an entire park day. It's especially fun for Disneyland and Disney World during spooky season.

Can I wear this to Oogie Boogie Bash?

YES. This one feels made for Oogie Boogie Bash. Pair it with biker shorts or jeans, comfortable park shoes, mouse ears, and villain-inspired accessories for an easy Halloween outfit.

What about Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party?

Definitely! It's a great choice for Mickey's Not-So-Scary Halloween Party, Oogie Boogie Bash, Disneyland Halloween, Disney World fall trips, Halloween parties, and any October park day.

Who would love this shirt?

Swifties, Disney adults, villain fans, Halloween lovers, Disney park regulars, The Tortured Poets Department fans, and anyone who appreciates an extremely specific fandom mashup.

What makes Friday Apparel different?

Friday Apparel creates subtle fandom-inspired apparel for fans who love stories, music, and clever references more than giant logos. Our designs are made for Disney park days, concerts, conventions, Halloween adventures, cozy weekends, and everyday outfits that quietly say, “If you know, you know.”

Share this Product